Carmen Winstead Pushed Down Sewer Story
The Carmen Winstead chain letter on Myspace has been circulating for a long time. It tells the story of a young girl named …
Carmen Winstead who was pushed down the sewer by 5 girls in her school, trying to embarrass her in front of her school during a fire drill. When she didn’t submerge the police were called. They went down and brought up 17 year old Carmen Winstead’s body, her neck broken from hitting the ladder, and then the side concrete at the bottom. The girls told everyone she fell… They believed them.
FACT: 2 months ago, 16 year old David Gregory read this post and didn’t repost it. When he went to take a shower he heard laughter from his shower, he started freaking out and ran to his computer to repost it. He said goodnight to his mom and went to sleep. 5 hours later his mom woke up in the middle of the night cause of a loud noise. David was gone. That morning a few hours later the police found him in the sewer, his neck broken and his face skin peeled off. Even google her name- you’ll find this to be true If you don’t repost this saying They hurt her then Carmen will get you, either from a sewer, the toilet, the shower, or when you go to sleep you’ll wake up in the sewer, in the dark, then Carmen will come and kill YOU
Ok, if you are wondering whether the story is true, I am sorry to tell you it’s just a myth. First of all, there’s no one named Carmen Winstead or Jessica Smith died in such way in Indiana or any other states in US. 6 years ago. This is just a typical prank letter preferred by some teens that requires you to repost it otherwise something bad will happen to you.
Source : Snopes
Carmen being pushed in a sewer by 5 girls to embarrass her is true.. actually the whole story is true. Either way, you shouldn’t call it bull. It would be better to keep your opinions to yourself.. what happened to her was terrible.. and people like that should be sentenced to prision for murder.
Fuck you bitch
This is a true story , when the girls pushed her down the sewer they hurt her . I believe that the girls should not have done that to her because bullying is not a good thing . If you was being bullied they would not have liked it . Anywayss the point is when they pushed her they hurt her .
the whole story is real but, im not to sure about the killings… those girls that did push carmen down the sewers should b punished for wat they did.. how she did die was very crucial and terrible…. the story overall is a tragedy
They hurt her!
I so believe this! I heard about 350 people died from this kind of murder and death. so i really believe in this, im not saying this to save my life but really i do believe in this!
They hurt her
The 5 girls hurt her! Those girls should have all been punished because what they did was cruel and I bet you that they wouldn’t have liked such a cruel death. They really hurt her!
THey hurt he and they dserve everything they get times 10 if u ask me.
This story i think isnt true. but i should say They hurt her!!!!!!!!
THey HURT HER
That wis terrible what they done
They hurt her.
they threw her in during a fire dril and she died form thoese girls.
this story isnt true at all!!!!!!!!!i think those 5 girls were trying to be cool
Hey , um i’m not sure if true , but if it is who ever did such thing this should be on their conciseness for EVER , this is wrong , but carmen shouldnt go around hurting people , the chain letter should be passed around to understand that this is a WONR action , ‘ but other then that i did send it , ‘ im not sure if this is a myth or a true thing because a few weeks ago this was sent to my mothers cell phone & my father told me to delete it & nothing happened , because if you belive in god your ALWAYS safe
well thank you for the help u reminded me that god will be there for us
HMM IDK IF 2 BELIEVE ITS TRUE OR NOT -_^ ?
..BUT EITHER WAY.. THEY HURT HER !!!!
[:
They hurt her!
this story is not true
lol…
its a chain letter none if it is true if you ask me it deserves a biq lauqh they just want to scare people it NEVER said its true and where it saids fact those are the exact words in the chain letter its not true
₩Θ₩ they я very mean an they didn’t go ² jail :-p ₩Θ₩ ₩Θ₩ ₩Θ₩ ₩Θ₩ ₩Θ₩ ₩Θ₩
:’( even tha its not real if this happened that will β sad 
i think that its true because i have seen videos about this story on youtube
this is total rubbish Grace dont worry yourself over it and get on with your life, these pathetic chain letters are aimed at younger people to upset them…xxx
thinks you sad people who make up this shit are seriously pathetic, maybe a girl was pushed which wud of been sick but what the story has turned into about bein killed is even more sick, all them people worryin themselves over it should just get on with life and IGNORE THIS..!!!!!!
is it really true? because i think it is. my friend got this then went missing and is still missing. please tell me because i got it too today. my friend got it about a week ago. oh please help me. thanks.
They hurt her. Jessica, Sarah, Amanda, Tiffany, and Holly.
the girls are already being punished. not in jail, in their lives.
carmens thought are in their heads. the flashback bothers them.
carmen made Sarah die in a car crash. Holly was found choked with her lucky blue scarf, head in the toilet. i honestly dont know what to think but those girls did n fact hurt her….
BEFORE YOU READ THIS THESE ARE THE STORY I PICKED OFF THE INTERNET I DO BELIEVE IN THESE STORIES.I GOT A TEXT ABOUT A GIRL NAMED JORDAN AND I DIDN’T SEND IT! I’M FINE! MOSTLY THE REASON I DIDN’T SEND THE STORY WAS BECAUSE MY PHONE CAN’T SENd MULTI SLIDES………AND IT WAS A MULTI SLIDE SO I’M POSTING THEM ON THE INTERNET.I DON’T BELIEVE THE PART ABOUT THEM COMING BACK.WHY WOULD ANYONE WANT SOMEONE THEY DON’T EVEN KNOW TO SUFER LIKE THEY DID.MOST OF THE STORIES OTHER PEOPLE DID THIS TO THEM.WHY WOULD ANYONE WANT TO MAKE ELSE TO FEEL THE PAIN THEY FELT BECAUSE OF A CHAIN LETTER??
There were NOT 5 students it was only 1.Her name was Nichole and she hated Carmen.She was jealous so one day durning a fire drill she went over to Carmen pretending to nice and said “I can’t her you over here,let’s go to the construction cones by the sewer.” Carmen was thinking nothing of Nichole’s nicess and said “Ok” they went by the construction cones and started talking. About a few minutes later Nichole pushed her down and said “That’s what you get Carmen!!!” Carmen’s friend Stacy run over to To the sewer.Carmen was screaming and trying to catch on to the ladder befor she fell.Sadly she didn’t catch the ladder as she planned.She ended up breaking her neck on the ladder and falling. When she did not return Nichole went to a teacher and told her “Stacy pushed Carmen!She pushed her down the sewer!Carmen Didn’t come back up!”.The teacher believed her and called the police. A week later Nichole killed her self because the guilt. Stacy was questioned for Nichole and Carmen’s deaths.She had a recording of Nichole saying “That’s what you get Carmen!!” And now they know it was Nichole who killed Carmen. ANOTHER STORY ABOUT CARMEN: Carmen was fighting with her mom about curfew (as most teens she thought 8:30 was not a reasonable timing to come back home.) Carmen had came home late (about 12:30) from a party she had went to.Carmen had a few drinks at this party but she only took them because at the party all they had to drink was Teqila,Beer,and Vodka. Carmen’s mom had been waiting for her and started yelling at Carmen for being late. “I don’t have to listen to you!” Carmen yelled then took a swing. Carmen’s mother douged with her fist to Carmen’s neck. Carmen snapped her neck and landed on the kitchen floor.Panicing Carmen’s mother grabbed a knife and started chopping Carmen into peices.She flushed them down the toilet and some of the chunks were found in the sewer.
they hurt her!!!
dunno if it’s true or not, but just in case x
THEY HURT HER!!!
Just incase xx
they hurt her
Guys this is not real i got this yesterday and i am perfectly fine i have also recived many other chains like this and i have a perfectly happy life!
i got the tex message so i googled it but im not sure tbh
they hurt her
sorry not sure if i believe it
they hurt her
You guys really ought to get a fucking life!
this story is true wow never believed all those wierd random text now i do its freakyy
let me ask you, if you believe in ghosts? you would reply nope. Now this is a load of shit that teenagers are making up to scare people like us. This is wasting your time and will make you shit your pants when you go into the bathroom. people scaring others and making fools of you. This story is to make juveniles waste their credit and times texting this shit story to ten people. You honestly believe in this shit. You’ll see my name come up tommorow on google saying i died in a sewer? I don’t give a fucking fuck. This is totally shit.
thank u
Well, so far I’m still here.
I wish the fuck wit that sent the text to my wife would get herself a life.She’s a middle aged woman (the sender) and not a bloody teenager that has no sense and should know better.
Thankfully my wife has an IQ over ten (11!) and paid no attention to it.If people REALLY believe in all this crap then they need specialist help. Before anyone asks why I am on this site,it’s because I saw it mentioned on Google and that is the ONLY reason.
For all those that DO believe in this, have a good life when you finally get one!
JD
THEY FUCKED HER
omg tht is sick i got it in a tx and it sayed google it so i did and im kinda freaked out by it but its sad becuz they hurt her
ahh… this is creepy
i mean, I’m ten alredy and this realy scared me
the piktures are even worse
poor Carmen
Is it true?
The piktures couldn’t be photoshoped… rite?
they looked so real…
Thats a really scary way to kill someone
what if i die? D:
Is that why ur up so late? =.=”
erm y do u say :
‘they hurt her’
THEY HURT HER!!!
Just incase
R.I.P xx
the five girls trew herdown just to embarrace her
they hurt her
they hurt her
o my gosh they hurt her
they hurt her!!!!!
I believe they should be in someone’s kinsey center for kids for the way they acted. Her people should come and beat the shit out of them little dumbass bitches b/c if it was me they would have gotten worse.
Okay, even though it ain’t true that is what I would do if it happened to me or anyone else that I love!!!!!!!
THEY HURT HER!
they hurt her
I find it funny so many people believe this! FACT is this NEVER happened!! I have gotten a text message twice about it i never sent either one of them and im STILL here! But if this was real that would a terrible thing to happen to her, but indeed it isn’t. Sorry to crush you spirit… Wait! I ain’t sorry:) haha.
they hurt her
Well.. i found out about this story off my phone in a forward, at first i didnt believe it! but then it said look it up in google sooo i did and ive read two stories about it and i believe it now! although out of the two stories it tends to change! one david dies, and in thee other all the five girlss dieee
Pschhhh those five girls embaressing should of woken them up out of b*****s
♥carmen winstead
this is stupid. in the txt i got she was blak. my friend had 1 were she was white. and another 1 with white but tottally dif facial features. hoax!!!
they hurt her!